602-900-7625
Free Consultation
A DV Assault charge with a felony Aggravated Assault threat held over the case to pressure a plea. Future First filed Notice of Defenses, rejected the State’s reduced plea, and forced the case to bench trial. The State’s law enforcement witness fell through and the case was dismissed in full.
At a glance
| Court | San Tan Justice Court |
| Original charge | Assault (ARS § 13-1203(A)(1)) with domestic violence designation, Class 1 Misdemeanor (felony Aggravated Assault DV threat held over case) |
| Presumptive exposure | Up to 180 days jail, up to $2,500 fine plus 78% surcharge, DV offender treatment program, no-contact order, restitution, $300 stipulated fine plus $100 DV-specific assessments; felony escalation risk under Aggravated Assault DV |
| State’s reduced offer (refused) | Amended plea to Disorderly Conduct DV C1M with probation, DV treatment, fines, no-contact terms |
| Result | Case dismissed in full at trial readiness after State’s law enforcement witness was unavailable |
| Conviction | None |
| Eligibility for sealing | Immediate under ARS § 13-911 in 2022 (case ended in dismissal) |
The stakes
The client was arrested after a 911 call from a roommate’s adult child reporting a fight at the home. Officers documented injuries on both the client and the other party, but only the client was booked. Body-worn camera audio captured an officer saying the situation was hard to call without witnesses but “either way” they wanted the client booked.
The State filed Assault, Domestic Violence as a Class 1 misdemeanor under ARS § 13-1203(A)(1) and held a felony Aggravated Assault, Domestic Violence threat over the case to pressure a plea. The client faced up to 6 months in jail, up to $2,500 in fines, mandatory domestic violence offender treatment, a no-contact order, restitution, and a stacked DV history that would have made any future incident chargeable as a felony.
What we did
After Future First filed a Notice of Defenses pleading self-defense, insufficiency of evidence, defense of property, lack of culpable mental state, mistake of fact, and accident, then sent a detailed deviation letter walking the prosecutor through the 911 audio, body-worn camera, and credibility problems with the complaining witness, the firm refused the State’s reduced plea to Disorderly Conduct DV and pushed the case to bench trial.
At trial readiness, the State’s law enforcement witness was unavailable and the case was dismissed in full. No conviction entered. The client is eligible to seal the arrest record now under ARS § 13-911 (2022). Set-aside under ARS § 13-905 does not apply because no conviction entered.
What our clients say
Future First Criminal Law has earned hundreds of five-star reviews from clients across Arizona. Read our verified Google reviews or see what past clients have said on our client reviews page.
If you’re facing a DV assault charge in Arizona
Arizona’s Notice of Defenses procedure under Rule 15.2 lets the defense formally identify every theory of defense the case can support. On a DV assault case with mutual injuries, ambiguous complaining-witness statements, and any third-party contact issues, the defense can plead self-defense, defense of property, lack of culpable mental state, mistake of fact, accident, and insufficiency of evidence in the same notice. Each one shifts the State’s burden in a different direction.
The State’s path of least resistance on a DV case with proof problems is usually to offer a reduced plea to Disorderly Conduct DV. That offer still carries the lifetime federal firearm prohibition and the mandatory DV counseling. Accepting it gets the conviction off the assault charge but keeps the DV designation. Refusing it keeps the trial-track open and forces the State to either prove the case at trial or dismiss.
Witness-failure dismissals at trial readiness happen more often on DV cases than most defendants expect. The complaining witness may decide not to participate. The law enforcement witness may become unavailable for scheduling reasons. The State has to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt with the witnesses actually in the courtroom; when those witnesses do not appear, the case is at risk of dismissal.
Future First Criminal Law has handled DV assault cases across Maricopa County and Arizona. We know how San Tan Justice Court and other justice courts handle Notice of Defenses filings, deviation letters, and bench trial readiness, and when to push a case to trial rather than accept a reduced plea.
Related resources
- Arizona criminal defense — full overview of how we handle misdemeanor and felony charges
- Set aside and sealing in Arizona — how to clean up your record after a DV dismissal or conviction
Call us
Facing a DV assault charge in Arizona? Call Future First Criminal Law at 602-900-7625 or request a free consultation. We have handled hundreds of DV cases across Arizona. The earlier we are involved, the more options you have for Notice of Defenses, deviation letters, and trial-track dismissals.
Anonymized in line with firm policy. Client name not used. Specific dates approximated to year only. Outcome described reflects this client’s actual results. Past outcomes do not guarantee future results. For more detailed information on Arizona domestic violence law, visit the Arizona State Legislature website.