The client walked into Scottsdale City Court facing three misdemeanor counts, including a theft charge and a charge of failing to obey a police officer. Future First negotiated the case down to a single Class 3 misdemeanor, criminal trespass in the third degree, with no jail. Getting the Scottsdale theft charge dismissed kept the two most serious counts off the record.

At a glance

Court Scottsdale City Court
Original charges Three counts: theft (ARS § 13-1802(A)(1)) and failure to obey a police officer (Scottsdale City Code § 19-13), both Class 1 misdemeanors, plus criminal trespass in the third degree (ARS § 13-1502(A)(1)), a Class 3 misdemeanor
Exposure Up to 6 months in jail, a fine up to $2,500 plus surcharge, and up to 3 years of probation on each Class 1 misdemeanor count
Result Plea to a single Class 3 misdemeanor, criminal trespass in the third degree. Both Class 1 counts dismissed. No jail, no probation
Eligibility for set aside Eligible approximately 2026, after completing court terms
Eligibility for sealing Eligible approximately 2028

The stakes

The client was charged in Scottsdale City Court with three misdemeanor counts after an incident at a crowded public event. Two of the three were Class 1 misdemeanors: a theft charge under ARS § 13-1802 and a charge of failing to obey a police officer. A Class 1 misdemeanor in Arizona carries up to 6 months in jail, a fine up to $2,500 plus surcharge, and up to 3 years of probation.

The third count, criminal trespass in the third degree under ARS § 13-1502(A)(1), was a Class 3 misdemeanor, the lowest tier in the case. Convictions on the two Class 1 counts would have left a permanent record showing theft and defiance of law enforcement. That kind of record follows a person through job applications, housing, and licensing for years.

What we did

Future First worked through the State’s discovery in detail. The reports had weaknesses in how the incident was documented and how the client was identified. Future First built a deviation package around those gaps and pressed the prosecutor for a resolution that matched the actual conduct.

The result: the Scottsdale theft charge dismissed, along with the Class 1 failure to obey count. The client pleaded to the single lowest-tier charge, criminal trespass in the third degree, a Class 3 misdemeanor. The court imposed no jail and no probation. The sentence was $440.11 in fines and fees plus substance abuse screening and counseling. Trading two Class 1 misdemeanor convictions for one Class 3 misdemeanor with no jail protects the client’s record and keeps the door open for a later set aside and sealing.

What our clients say

Read reviews from Future First clients on Google and on our client reviews page.

If you’re facing a theft charge in Arizona

Theft and trespass charges often come out of a single chaotic moment, especially at crowded events where security and police move fast. Police tend to book every count that might apply, which stacks exposure and pressures a fast guilty plea. The charge you are booked on is not the charge you have to accept.

The defense work is in the detail. Body-worn camera, security video, witness statements, and the sequence of events often show a weaker case than the report suggests. In this case, getting a Scottsdale theft charge dismissed came down to attacking the identification and the gaps in the State’s proof, then giving the prosecutor a reason to drop to the lowest count. A well-built deviation packet can move a prosecutor from the top counts to a single lower-tier plea or to dismissal. The goal is to protect the record, avoid jail, and keep the door open for a later set aside and sealing.

Related resources

Call us

Facing a theft, trespass, or other misdemeanor charge in Arizona? Call Future First Criminal Law at 602-932-7890 or request a free consultation. We build the deviation, work the prosecutor, and fight to keep your record clean.


Anonymized in line with firm policy. Client name not used. Specific dates approximated to year only. Outcome described reflects this client’s actual results. Past outcomes do not guarantee future results. For more detailed information on Arizona criminal law, visit the Arizona State Legislature website.